Manuscript Flowchart

Peer review flowchart

The entire editorial procedure for a contribution - from submission to publication - is automatic and carried out electronically.

Authors, editors and reviewers run their specific stages of the editorial procedure through personal web pages. An integrated system of notifications, online alerts and reminders helps users keep track of the due actions.

The editorial office, the directors and all users involved in a manuscript can be contacted at any time by means of the "Write a message" button available in the "Actions" panel of the manuscript page. This must always be used for communications instead of normal e-mails (see also "Communications").

The following image shows the typical manuscript flowchart from submission to production. Publication takes place on a rolling basis thereafter.

Statuses and Actions

The following table shows the different stages in which a manuscript can be and the expected action.

Status What happened Possible actions Action expected of
Assigned to Editor A new submission has come in and has been assigned to the editor in charge
  • Select reviewer and/or click "I will review"
  • Decline the assignment (a new editor in charge will be chosen by the directors)
  • Make a decision (without review)
Editor in charge
In review One or more reviewers have been selected (can include the editor themselves) and at least one report is still expected
  • Send report
Reviewer / editor in charge (if the editor previously clicked "I will review")
Waiting for decision All requested reports have come in
  • Make decision
  • Select another reviewer and/or click "I will review"
Editor in charge
Major/minor revision requested The editor in charge has requested the authors to revise their manuscript (either major or minor changes)
  • Submit revision
  • Confirm previous version
Author
Resubmitted major/minor revision The author has re-submitted their manuscript
  • Select reviewer and/or click "I will review"
  • Decline the assignment (a new editor in charge will be chosen by the directors)
  • Make a decision (without review)
Editor in charge
Appeal open The author would like to appeal again rejection and the process has been opened by the editorial office
  • Submit revision
  • Confirm previous version
Author
Appeal submitted The author has re-submitted their manuscript for reconsideration in JCAP
  • Select reviewer and/or click "I will review"
  • Decline the assignment (a new editor-in-charge will be chosen by the directors)
  • Make a decision (without review)
Editor in charge
Rejected/Not Suitable The editor in charge has issued a "Rejected" or a "Not suitable" decision. The manuscript is no longer unders consideration in JCAP.
  • Appeal against rejection
Author
Ready for typesetter The Editor in charge has accepted the manuscript for publication
  • Tyepetting
Typesetter
Proofreading The manuscript has been typeset and sent the author for proofreading OR the corrections/replies to queries sent by the author have been implemented and the manuscript has been sent back to them for a final check before publication
  • Send corrections/reply to queries
  • Declare "Ready for publication" (if there are no typesetter's queries to reply)
Author
Ready for publication The production stage is complete and the manuscript is ready to be published
  • Publish
Editorial Office
Published The manuscript has been published in JCAP
  • Submit erratum/addendum
Author