Guidelines for Editors

General

Editors-in-charge are crucial for the smooth running of JCAP: they select expert reviewers, guaranteeing the highest quality standards and pursuing timely editorial processing of contributions. Indeed, the journal relies heavily on the editor's scientific qualifications, competence, promptness and commitment for quality and efficiency. Editorial oversight and peer review is handled anonymously.

Manuscripts are automatically assigned to the most appropriate editor-in-charge. The editor's workload is taken into account in the distribution of the assignments and overload is avoided insofar as possible.

As soon as a submission is assigned to an editor-in-charge, they receive an email notification asking them to log in to the JCAP website to manage it. The Editorial Office will soon follow-up to provide the necessary information and assistance. General information about the JCAP system (login, correspondence, etc.) is available in "Using the JCAP system".

Here are some basic instructions on how to manage a submission: Instruction for Editors

Editors-in-charge are notified by email about all important events and of all messages addressed to them. Emails invite editors to access the manuscript page and see the details and/or take action.

Editors-in-charge are expected to carry out their tasks according to the Journal Editorial Policy and Ethical Policy.

The JCAP Editorial Board is available at this link.

At the end of the review process, editors-in-charge prepare the "Editor report" to motivate their decision. Possible decisions in JCAP are:

  • Acceptance
  • Rejection
  • Declaration of "Not Suitable"
  • Request for major revision
  • Request for minor revision

Revised versions can be submitted by authors only if requested by the editor-in-charge and should be evaluated with the same quality stadards as new submissions.

Automatic reminders are sent in case of delays in all stages of the procedure.

Guidelines for payment

In the spirit that scientists’ work must be compensated, JCAP has been paying editors for their peer-review work since its inception and reviewers since 2008. This long-standing practice sets JCAP apart in the academic publishing landscape

When is the payment made?

Payments are normally made once a year, after the editor has made their final decision (accept, reject or not suitable). For final decisions made in 2026, editors-in-charge will be sent an email in 2027 with full instructions to receive their payment

What do Editors need to do?

To qualify for payment editors are expected both to bear in mind the high quality standards set by the journal and to use in full the potential of the web system, taking all the steps required by the automatic editorial procedure for editorial work. Moreover, editors are requested to meet the deadlines or inform the editorial office if a postponement cannot be avoided.

These steps are necessary because editor payments are calculated through the editorial system. If the required procedure is not followed, we may not be able to pay the editor fee.

Donations

It is also possible to opt for a donation of the amount due. Donations support initiatives, products and provide financial help for the benefit of the scientific community, as described here: https://jcap.sissa.it/site/donations/

Payments affected by sanctions
If payments to editor cannot be made because their country of residence or bank account is subject to sanctions imposed under Italian or European regulations, the amount due will be set aside and paid when the applicable restrictions are lifted.
 
Thank you for contributing your time and expertise to JCAP and to the scientific community.

Flowchart of a manuscript

🔎 Click here for information about manuscript flowchart

F.A.Q. for editors-in-charge

🔎 Click here to access the F.A.Q. for editors-in-charge.