Editorial Policy
- Can I change the keywords after the submission?
- I have prepared a new version after the submission. Can I upload it?
- Who are the submitting author and the corresponding author in JCAP?
- Can I add/remove coauthors after the manuscript has been submitted/accepted?
- Who is the editor handling my manuscript? Why do editors remain anonymous?
- Can I suggest reviewer for my manuscript?
- The refereeing on my manuscript is taking longer than expected. What can I do?
- What if I need to make corrections, or additions after the manuscript has been published?
- Can I update the arXiv record once my manuscript has been accepted for publication in JCAP?
- What can I do if my manuscript is rejected?
- What can I do if my manuscript receives a "Not suitable" decision?
- What is the Journal’s policy on data files and similar supplementary material?
Can I change the keywords after the submission?
No, keywords cannot be changed after a manuscript's submission, because they are the crucial element in deciding who the editor in charge will be, and therefore how the peer review process is determined.
I have prepared a new version after the submission. Can I upload it?
No. Once submitted, manuscripts should not be replaced. If the new version differs substantially, manuscripts can be withdrawn and resubmitted.
Who are the submitting author and the corresponding author in JCAP?
Submitting author: author who submits their paper to the Journal, taking responsibility for ehat is being submitted and ensuring thatany and all coauthors have participated in the creation of the manuscript and have approved the final version for submission to JCAP. They can either act as the corresponding author or select another author for this role.
Corresponding author: can coincide with the person making the submission or can be a different author, selected by the submitting author during the submission process. Corresponding authors are notified of decisions and requested to take action in the various steps of the editorial process. After submission, they sign the Assignment of Copyright for on behalf of themselves and their coauthors. NB: depending on the corresponding author's affiliation(s), as written on the pdf file and associated to their JCAP profile, the manuscript may be granted Open Access publication in the framework of Transformative Agreements (see below).
Can I add/remove coauthors after the manuscript has been submitted/accepted?
The submitting author of manuscripts submitted to JCAP is responsible for the accuracy of information regarding coauthors. If coauthors need to be added/removed between submission and the editor's final decision, the corresponding author should write the Editor-in-charge requisting them to allow a metadata change. Once granted, the corresponding author will be able to modify the author list explaining the reasons for this change and how each listed author has contributed to the manuscript. The Editor-in-charge will decide on a case-by-case basis whether the modification can be approved.
For integrity reasons, no change in the author list will be accepted after acceptance for publication.
Who is the editor handling my manuscript? Why do editors remain anonymous?
The Editorial Board is composed of distinguished and active scientists in the field. Editors in JCAP are selected automatically through an algorithm based on the keywords selected by the authors at submission. After the manuscript is assigned to an editor, the editor usually seeks the advice of one or more expert reviewers, but may, on the other hand, decide to review the manuscript autonomously. Editors and reviewers generally operate anonymously in order to guarantee an unbiased handling of manuscripts, but are free to reveal their identity to the authors if they so wish.
Can I suggest reviewer for my manuscript?
Yes, upon submission, you can use the Cover Letter text area to suggest suitable reviewers for your manuscript. However, the editor-in-charge of the manuscript is under no obligation to contact them.
The refereeing on my manuscript is taking longer than expected. What can I do?
The Editor-in-charge and the Editorial Office will carefully follow the processing of your manuscript and will do their best to avoid any delays, while favouring quality over speed. It can be a challenge to ensure timely responses, and the process may at times take longer than planned. You will be able to get in touch with the Editor-in-charge at any time to inquire about the status by using the "Write a message" button on the manuscript page.
What if I need to make corrections or additions after the manuscript has been published?
The only way to modify a published manuscript is by means of an erratum/addendum.
Can I update the arXiv record once my manuscript has been accepted for publication in JCAP?
Yes. JCAP encourages authors to update their manuscript's arXiv record with the JCAP's accepted or published version, adding a link to the JQuant manuscript page through its DOI.
What can I do if my manuscript is rejected?
Authors can request to appeal a rejection decision by contacting the Editorial Office via the "Write a message" tool. Appeals must be scientifically justified and not polemic and authors are asked to send a rebuttal letter explaining the scientific reasons behind their request. If rebuttals are considered acceptable and an appeal is granted, the new round of review may be assigned to the same editor or to a new one on a case by case basis.
If the rejection is confirmed after an appeal, requests for second appeals will never be considered unless there is a clear history of unfair treatment of the manuscript. Appeals should be requested within a year's time, after which manuscripts will only be considered as new submissions, in which case a new arXiv ID number must be provided.
To guarantee fair treatment, the processing of appeals is always supervised by the Scientific Director.
What can I do if my manuscript receives a "Not suitable" decision?
Not suitable decisions cannot be appealed. This kind of decision, in fact, indicates that the manuscript does not fall within the scope of the Journal and cannot be considered for publication, either because the subject matter is not relevant for it, or because it does not meet its standards.
What is the Journal’s policy on data files and similar supplementary material?
JCAP strongly encourages posting data files and similar supplementary material to publicly-accessible, discipline-specific, community-recognised repositories that comply with the FAIR principles as much as possible.
In cases where a suitable discipline-specific resource does not exist, such files may be submitted to a generalist repository (for example, Zenodo), including any such repositories provided by universities, funders or institutions for their affiliated researchers. Authors may also wish to explore repository registries such as FAIRsharing.org and re3data.org.
Supplementary material should conform to the FAIR principles as much as possible.
During submission, authors are requested to declare if there is code or software connected to the manuscript and if/where it can be accessed. This information should also be included at the end of the manuscript, in sections named "Code Availability Statement" and "Data Availability Statement".
Other supplementary material can be submitted to JCAP as Electronic Supplementary Material (ESM) along with the manuscript. ESM are received by reviewers but are not typeset or altered in any way in case of publication.
Finally, any infromation or file that should be received by the Editorial Office only or by the Administrative department and that is neither needed for the review nor for publication, should be submitted along with the manuscript as "Administrative files".
Access to published manuscripts, copyright and licensing
- Do I have to pay to publish in JCAP?
- What publication options does JCAP offer?
- When and how do I choose an access option?
- Can my institution or other funders cover Gold Open Access?
- What if my Transformative Agreement funding is not approved?
- How much is the APC, and when is payment due?
- Why did my manuscript’s access mode change during review?
- Can I change my access choice after submission?
- Does Gold Open Access affect peer review?
- Can I share my manuscript on arXiv or another repository?
- Who owns the copyright?
- What rights do I keep under subscription publication?
- What does CC BY 4.0 allow?
- Who completes the copyright paperwork, and when?
- What if I am affiliated with CERN?
- Who can help?
Do I have to pay to publish in JCAP?
- There is no Article Processing Charge (APC) simply to submit a manuscript or publish under the subscription model.
- If you choose author-funded Gold Open Access (i.e, "Open Access paid by author"), payment of an APC will be requested of you after acceptance.
- If your article qualifies for Open Access publication under a Transformative Agreement, the charge is normally covered by the corresponding author's institution, subject to final approval after your article’s acceptance for publication.
Further information: Publication charges
What publication options does JCAP offer?
- Under subscription publication, the articles’ final version is accessible to subscribers, while the accepted version may be shared through repositories (Green Open Access).
- Under Gold Open Access, the published article is freely accessible to everyone under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 (CC BY 4.0) licence. Gold Open Access may be paid for by the author or a third party, or funded through an eligible Transformative Agreement.
Further information: JCAP copyright and licence information
When and how do I choose an access option?
At submission, JCAP checks the corresponding author’s affiliation against potentially applicable IOP Publishing agreements. If a possible Transformative Agreement match is identified, the system will provisionally assign that route. Otherwise, authors may choose subscription publication or author-funded Gold Open Access (“Open Access paid by author”). The access route does not influence editorial assessment. Check the settings displayed on your manuscript web page → “Author’s declarations” and contact the Editorial Office through “Write a message” if the setting appears incorrect.
Can my institution or other funders cover Gold Open Access?
Possibly. Coverage in the framework of Transformative Agreements depends on the corresponding author’s institution, on whether it has a Transformative Agreement in place with JCAP publishing partner’s IoPP and on whether funds are available after your manuscript has been accepted for publication. In case your article is potentially covered by a Transformative Agreement and funds turn out not to be available after acceptance for publication, the Editorial Office will set an alternative Access Mode of your choice. If No Transformative Agreements are applicable but you have grants available to cover for Article Processing Charges (APC), please opt for “Open access paid by author”, in which case you will be requested to do the payment yourself after your manuscript’s acceptance.
Further information: Transformative Agreements | Journal Finder
What if my Transformative Agreement funding is not approved?
Do not assume that provisional eligibility guarantees funding. If coverage is declined, the Editorial Office will reach out to let you choose an alternative.
How much is the APC, and when is payment due?
The current APC should be checked on the journal’s official charges information or IOP Publishing’s Journal Finder. No APC is due at submission or during peer review. For author-funded Gold Open Access, the corresponding author or designated payer is contacted following acceptance.
Further information: Publication charges | Journal Finder
Why did my manuscript’s access mode change during review?
A manuscript’s access mode can be updated as the corresponding author’s affiliation or agreement details change. In particular, the setting “Open Access - Transformative Agreement” during peer review is provisional; final eligibility is confirmed after the manuscript’s acceptance for publication. If in doubt, use “Write a message” on your JCAP manuscript page to contact the Editorial Office.
Can I change my access choice after submission?
Before acceptance, contact the Editorial Office by using the button “write a message” on your manuscript web page. For changes after acceptance, contact permissions@ioppublishing.org.
Does Gold Open Access affect peer review?
No. JCAP applies the same editorial assessment and peer-review standards regardless of the publication route. Gold Open Access affects availability and reuse permissions after publication, not the scientific evaluation.
Can I share my manuscript on arXiv or another repository?
The rules depend on the manuscript version and its access / copyright / licence settings.
- Gold Open Access manuscripts are usually released with a CC BY 4.0 licence, meaning that anyone is free to re-use the manuscript’s final version in full or in part without permission provided the original source is properly attributed.
- In case of subscription-based publication, the accepted version may be posted to arXiv immediately upon publication (i.e, with no embargo) and or to other repositories after a 12-month embargo.
In any case, a non-exclusive licence should be chosen when posting manuscripts on external repositories. Please refer to the Assignment of Copyright form or Licence Agreement that you will be requested to publish after publication for the details, which may change in some cases.
Further information: JCAP copyright and licence information | CC BY 4.0 licence
Who owns the copyright?
For subscription publication, copyright is transferred to the Publisher, with certain rights reserved to authors. Exceptions may apply in specific cases. The Assignment of Copyright form that authors are requested to sign after acceptance will details the exact rights.
For Gold Open Access, the copyright normally remains with the authors or relevant employer/institution, while the publishers receive a non-exclusive licence to publish.
Further information: JCAP copyright and licence information
What rights do I keep under subscription publication?
The precise rights are set out in the copyright agreement and should not be inferred solely from the phrase “copyright transfer”. Consult the applicable agreement for permitted teaching, presentation, dissertation, reuse and repository activities, and for any attribution requirements.
Further information: JCAP instructions for subscription articles
What does CC BY 4.0 allow?
For Gold Open Access articles, CC BY 4.0 allows others to share and adapt the licensed material, including commercially, provided they give appropriate credit, link to the licence and indicate changes. Material credited to third parties may have separate restrictions. Authors or institutional owners generally retain copyright under this route.
Further information: Read the CC BY 4.0 licence
Who completes the copyright paperwork, and when?
The appropriate publication agreement is completed after acceptance. JCAP’s author instructions describe the signing process, including the need for the signing author to have the co-authors’ authority and special treatment where an employer owns copyright. Check the instructions provided for your accepted article.
Further information: JCAP copyright and licence information
What if I am affiliated with CERN?
IOP Publishing has a Transformative Agreement with CERN.
Corresponding authors who are current CERN staff members, researchers — including permanent, temporary and visiting researchers — or students at CERN at the time of submission can be eligible to publish Open Access at no cost to themselves, subject to the terms of the agreement. CERN experimental collaborations can also be eligible. In such case, copyright vests to the Authors.
There is also a separate copyright arrangement for papers whose copyright is owned by CERN. In these cases, authors should notify JCAP at submission. A separate copyright form is not required because CERN articles are covered by a collective license agreement between CERN, SISSA Medialab and IOP Publishing.
Please note that being affiliated with CERN and having copyright owned by CERN are related but distinct questions. If you are unsure which arrangements apply to your article, please contact permissions@ioppublishing.org or CERN's Open Access service.
Further information: Institutional Open Access Agreements
Who can help?
- For copyright and licensing: permissions@ioppublishing.org
- For Article Processing Charges (APC): jcap@ioppublishing.org
- For any other question, please write the Editorial Office at SISSA Medialab: jcap-eo@jcap.sissa.it
If your query concerns a specific manuscript, please use the button “Write a message” on your manuscript web page.
Use of Artificial Intelligence (AI)
- Can AI be listed as an author?
- When must I disclose the use of AI?
- Does AI disclosure create a bias in the peer review process?
- What kind of AI use is prohibited?
- How do I disclose AI use?
- Can I use AI to create images or graphs?
- Who is responsible for AI-generated errors?
- What am I expected to check accurately when using an AI tool?
Can AI be listed as an author?
No. AI cannot be listed as an author or coauthor because tools are not legal entities capable of taking responsibility for the work.
When must I disclose the use of AI?
Disclosure is necessary when using generative AI to create text, generate figures, check analyses. Routine editing (spelling/grammar, translation) does not requires disclosure. In this case, please write “No AI-based tools have been used in preparing this manuscript".
Does AI disclosure create a bias in the peer review process?
No. In the current scholarly publishing climate, AI is accepted as a valid assistant if used responsibly and appropriately. Nonetheless, researchers must accept accountability when using generative AI to create text, figures, code etc… and trust the review process which requires they disclose how the different tools were used.
What kind of AI use is prohibited?
Authors should never use AI to create, manipulate, or fabricate research data and results.
How do I disclose AI use?
Disclose the specific tool (e.g., ChatGPT, Claude...) and how it was used in the appropriate field during the submission process. Include the name, version, and manufacturer of the tool as well as the prompts you used.
Can I use AI to create images or graphs?
Disclosure is mandatory if AI is used to create or edit data visualizations, illustrations, or images.
Who is responsible for AI-generated errors?
The authors are entirely responsible for the accuracy and integrity of the submitted work, including content assisted by AI.
What am I expected to check accurately when using an AI tool?
You must check the terms and conditions of any AI tool to ensure that the privacy and confidentiality of data and inputs of the material is guaranteed. Particular care should be taken with any personally identifiable data. Images that duplicate or refer to existing copyrighted images, real people, or others’ identifiable products or brands must not be generated. You should always check for factual errors and for any potential bias.
You must also ensure that constraints are not imposed on the use of outputs from the AI Tool in a way that could restrict the subsequent publication of the relevant article or collide with your copyright or the copyright of the journal or publishers.